In its 15-season run, Supernatural became known for its deep dive into mythology, urban legends, and its often self-aware humor. Among the show’s many standout episodes, actor Jared Padalecki has singled out one as his personal favorite: Season 6, Episode 15, titled “The French Mistake.”
The episode, which aired on February 25, 2011, quickly became a fan favorite for its unique concept and clever writing. Rated 9.6/10 on IMDb, “The French Mistake” exemplified Supernatural’s ability to balance humor and heart, while breaking the fourth wall in spectacular fashion.
A Meta Masterpiece
“The French Mistake” follows Sam and Dean Winchester—played by Padalecki and Jensen Ackles—as they are transported by the angel Balthazar into an alternate universe where they are no longer demon hunters, but actors on a TV show called Supernatural. There, they assume the roles of their real-life counterparts, Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles.
The episode includes numerous self-referential jokes, from Dean discovering his counterpart once starred in a soap opera, to Sam learning that “Jared” owns an alpaca and has a massive oil painting of himself on horseback. The script also pokes fun at key members of the Supernatural team, including executive producer Robert Singer and series creator Eric Kripke.
“It was absurd, brilliant, and exactly the kind of thing Supernatural did best,” Padalecki has said in interviews when describing why the episode stands out to him. It’s also a favorite among co-star Misha Collins and creator Kripke.
Misha Collins Takes the Joke Further
One of the episode’s most memorable elements is the portrayal of Misha Collins, who plays the angel Castiel in the series. In the alternate universe, Collins portrays an exaggerated version of himself—oblivious, vain, and overly enthusiastic about social media.
In a particularly meta twist, Collins’ character tweets live during events in the episode. Remarkably, Collins mirrored this fiction in real life, posting the same tweets from his official Twitter account the night the episode aired. These included:
“Omg. Did you guys see that?! Jensen and Jared just tried to kill me! I’m definitely going to tweet this one.”
“Ever get that feeling… someone’s in the backseat? :-(”
Though the final tweet is never sent within the episode—because the character is attacked before hitting “send”—Collins did post the others, adding an extra layer of immersion for fans.
Collins later revealed during a convention that he aimed to portray his fictional self as “as much of a douche as possible.” His performance, which included ignoring crew members and delivering increasingly bizarre tweets, has since become one of the most talked-about aspects of the episode.
Fan and Critical Praise
“The French Mistake” is widely regarded as one of the funniest and most inventive episodes of Supernatural. It blends satire, fantasy, and behind-the-scenes parody into a storyline that still resonates with fans. The contrast between the Winchesters’ grim reality and the artificial world of TV production served as a humorous but poignant commentary on identity and purpose.
The episode’s success lies in its layered writing and the cast’s willingness to laugh at themselves—something that Padalecki, Ackles, and Collins fully embraced. Its enduring popularity is a testament to the show’s creative risks and its bond with a loyal fanbase.
Related Topics